11

A relatively popular story ID subject (with six confirmed answers and several additional probable answers) has something of a mess with respect to duplicate management.

The first time that this was asked about was in Feb 2013, and it was answered and accepted then:

  1. 80's Animated movie: An old man joins mission to save a boy stranded on a hostile world

Some duplicates were later closed against it:

Some years later in May 2018, this movie was asked about and got an accepted answer for a fourth time:

  1. Animation movie (80's-90's) with brain-sucking insects

At that time, #1 was closed as a duplicate of #2, despite the fact that #1 was already a duplicate hub. This created a duplicate chain.

Some later duplicates have also been closed against #2:

In addition to a new question today that will be a duplicate if its answer is accepted (1980s sci-fi anime film with a scene where a human boy and an alien are walking through a swamp, and the alien is caught and killed by living vines), there is also an old question with an accepted answer that should be closed:

What's the best way to resolve this tangle and establish a proper hub question for current and future duplicates?

0

1 Answer 1

8

I pointed all the confirmed duplicates (new and old) to question 2: Animation movie (80's-90's) with brain-sucking insects

(I think this was the first time I had changed dupe targets without actually reopening any questions.)

2
  • 4
    When an ID question has a comment "This is probably one of the best story IDs I've seen" from one of the site's top reviewers, that's a pretty safe choice of dupe target. Good job with your (newish?) dupehammer powers.
    – Rand al'Thor Mod
    Commented Mar 15, 2022 at 9:53
  • +1 As the asker of the original Duplicate Hub, I agree that Question 2 above is the best choice as Duplicate Hub :) Commented Mar 25, 2022 at 9:15

You must log in to answer this question.

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.